South St. Louis County News

St. Louis Call Newspapers

South St. Louis County News

St. Louis Call Newspapers

South St. Louis County News

St. Louis Call Newspapers

Election results: Stenger wins, McCulloch loses, right-to-work fails

Pictured above: County Executive Steve Stenger and his wife, Allison, at his victory party in August 2018. Photo by Jessica Belle Kramer.

St. Louis County Executive Steve Stenger narrowly won the Democratic primary Tuesday against challenger Mark Mantovani, but longtime county Prosecuting Attorney Robert McCulloch lost to challenger Wesley Bell in a shocking defeat after nearly three decades in office.

Voters in south county and across the state overwhelmingly voted against Missouri becoming the next “right-to-work” state with the defeat of Proposition A.

Proposition A was defeated in St. Louis County 72.78 percent to 27.22 percent, 196,046 votes to 73,312.

St. Louis County Executive (Democratic)
Mark Mantovani vs. Steve Stenger

Victor: Steve Stenger

Stenger narrowly defeated Mantovani, although Mantovani said he was declining to concede with the prospect of a recount.

Stenger squeaked out the victory 50.32 percent to 49.68 percent, 91,487 votes to 90,330.

St. Louis County Prosecutor

Victor: Wesley Bell

In a victory that could be compared to David winning against Goliath, Ferguson City Councilman Wesley Bell soundly defeated longtime Prosecuting Attorney Robert McCulloch, backed by a grassroots campaign and support from nationwide groups like the ACLU.

Bell won 56.62 percent to 43.38 percent, or 103,018 votes to 78,934.

County Council 5th District

Victor: Lisa Clancy

Two-term incumbent Pat Dolan, D-Richmond Heights, lost to newcomer Lisa Clancy of Maplewood. Clancy took 57.76 percent of the vote to Dolan’s 35.97 percent, 17,978 votes to 11,196. Third contender Michael Burton’s name still appeared on the ballot despite him dropping out of the race last week. He earned 6.26 percent of the vote, or 1,949 votes.

Anatomy of two watch parties

Stenger and Ladue businessman Mark Mantovani sparred over a number of issues during the campaign, including Stenger’s relationship with the County Council.

In the initial absentee vote tallies released, incumbent Stenger initially led Mantovani by 500 votes. After not actively conducting a campaign specifically for absentees, Mantovani supporter former St. Louis Mayor Vince Schoemehl said at Mantovani’s watch party in Frontenac that the positioning was impressive.

Mark Mantovani talks with Amy Stuber of Creve Coeur and John Snodgrass of Richmond Heights at his watch party Tuesday after absentee results came in. Photo by Jessica Belle Kramer.

“We’re in for a long night, but it’s going to be a pretty fun party later on,” Schoemehl told the crowd.

Mantovani made several speeches at his watch party, but never conceded. He said he wrote two speeches depending on a defeat or a victory, but not a third option for a neck-and-neck race.

We’re kind of hanging on here by our fingernails,” Mantovani said. “But practically speaking, it doesn’t feel like the kind of thing you should concede.”

Across town at Stenger’s watch party at the LiUNA Event Center in Sunset Hills, Stenger didn’t emerge for five hours as the race remained close throughout the night and vote totals came in later than usual.

But when he did, he joked, “Another landslide,” referring to his narrow general-election victory in 2014 over Republican Rick Stream.

“This was a long hard fought campaign, but today’s victory shows that voters believe we’re moving St. Louis County in the right direction,” Stenger said. “We have brought real and positive change to St. Louis County over the last three-and-a half years.”

But Stenger said that he is not worried about a possible recount. In a recount after the race with Stream, Stenger gained votes.

Mantovani had a former city mayor on hand at his party, but Stenger’s party counted current St. Louis Mayor Lyda Krewson among his supporters.

I want to acknowledge Mark Mantovani for running a hard, aggressive campaign, and as you heard him just moments ago, he fought to the very end,” Stenger said in his victory speech.

He also promised to work with the County Council, acknowledging that his relationship with council members in the last few months has been “confrontational and sometimes downright hostile.” But the things he said he’d gotten done in St. Louis County, like an opioid prescription-drug monitoring program that spread to the rest of the state, Proposition P for more police officers and shoring up the county pension system, could not have been done without the council’s support, he noted.

He declined to talk about the defeats of his close allies McCulloch and Dolan, saying he would need a few days to process. But he pledged to work with Bell in his new office.

And he’s definitely taking the day off tomorrow, he said.

St. Louis County Charter amendments

Voters considered Proposition 2 and Proposition 3, amendments to the county Charter. A judge yanked Proposition 4, the campaign-finance Charter amendment, off the ballot. It still appeared, but votes weren’t counted.


Proposition 2, which would allow the County Council to hire its own attorney to counter the county counselor appointed by the county executive, passed by 11 votes, 50 percent to 50 percent, 124,685 votes to 124,674 votes.

Proposition 3 changes the definition of “employment” to match Missouri and IRS statutes and remove the Charter clause banning public employment of County Council members that could include independent contract work.

The amendment passed 54.74 percent to 45.26 percent, 132,428 votes to 109,493 votes.

St. Louis County Executive (Republican)
Paul Berry III vs. Daniel Sampson

Victor: Paul Berry III

Paul Berry III took the GOP nomination for county executive with 31,841 votes, or 56.48 percent, to Daniel Sampson’s 24,533 votes, or 43.52 percent.

Missouri House, 94th District (Republican)
Oakville, Green Park, Lemay
Jim Murphy vs. Ron Rammaha

Victor: Jim Murphy

Murphy easily won the race to succeed the late Rep. Cloria Brown with 70 percent of the vote to Ron Rammaha’s 30 percent, 1,742 votes to 746 votes.

Missouri House, 95th District (Republican)
Michael O’Donnell vs. Joe Patterson

Winner: O’Donnell

U.S. Navy veteran and financial professional O’Donnell narrowly defeated St. Louis County Police Association President Patterson, 51 percent to 49 percent, 2,030 votes to 1,947 votes.

Missouri House, 97th District (Republican)
Oakville, Concord, Arnold, Jefferson County
Phil Amato vs. Mary Elizabeth Coleman vs. David Linton

Victor: Mary Elizabeth Coleman

Former Arnold City Councilwoman Coleman appears to have won the GOP primary to face Rep. Mike Revis, R-Fenton, in November. Most of the district is in Jefferson County, but it has a sliver of south county in Oakville and Concord. In St. Louis County, she was beat by Linton, who was defeated by Revis in a special election in February. 
Linton took 42.64 percent of the vote, or 165 votes, to Coleman's 41.34 percent or 160 votes and former Arnold City Councilman Phil Amato's 62 votes, or 16 percent.

In Jefferson County, Coleman earned 1,612 votes, 43.14 percent. Amato took 860 votes for 23 percent and Linton took 1,265 votes, or 33.85 percent.


More to Discover