The St. Louis County Planning Commission voted unanimously to hold the Ruprecht Quarry conditional use permit (CUP) proposal until Fillworks LLC is able to provide additional answers to the commissioners’ questions. The decision took place at the Planning Commission’s executive meeting on Nov. 9.
Though the St. Louis County Department of Planning said that Fillworks’ proposal passes the four-pronged CUP test, further action will wait until the commission receives more information from the company.
“The department finds that the request is appropriate, subject to extensive conditions,” a presentation by the county planning department stated. “(It) creates a pathway forward toward future productive use of the property and provides regulatory oversight through the Conditional Use Permit process.”
According to the planning department, the four-pronged CUP test includes that the proposal is “a) not detrimental to permitted developments and uses in the Non-Urban District b) visually compatible with permitted uses in surrounding area c) desirable to preserve and promote public health, safety and welfare and d) consistent with good planning practice.”
In order to satisfy these conditions, the planning department is recommending these extensive conditions: outlining permitted and prohibited uses; preserving neighborhood access on streets; protecting the condition of Mount Olive Road; oversight of fill material; reducing negative visual impact; restoring the landscape in compliance with local, state and federal regulations; establishing oversight prior to site construction; reporting requirements annually and at the close of the project as well as establishing general development conditions.
The project, if approved, would fill the inactive 30-acre Lemay quarry with “clean fill.” Fillworks estimates this project will take eight to 12 years to complete, with construction crews at work six days a week: from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. on weekdays and 7 a.m. to 5 p.m. on Saturday. Approximately 100 to 150 trucks per day would be coming in and out of the site, which is surrounded by residential neighborhoods and cemeteries.
Commissioners are requesting Fillworks provide more information about the flow and timing of trucks coming in and out of the site. Additionally, the Planning Commission is set to receive annual reports about site operations, progress, materials, ground vibrations, compaction operations, the roadway and pavement conditions on Mount Olive Road and more. Some commissioners expressed interest in receiving more frequent updates from Fillworks.
Many residents living near Ruprecht Quarry have been vocally against the project. The Planning Commission reviewed numbers at the Nov. 9 meeting: at a public hearing in July, there were 13 speakers in opposition of the project and zero speakers in favor. When taking a crowd count at the public hearing, two crowd members were in favor and 27 were in opposition.
Between July 13 and Oct. 23, the Planning Department received 102 written comments in opposition, five comments in support, nine comments in support with additional developmental conditions and six were “neutral, miscellaneous or process-related inquiries.”
If the Planning Commission approves the proposal, District 6 Councilman Mike Archer says that he will ask to call a Public Improvements Committee meeting where interested parties could come before the council and voice their opinions. He expects that there would be a 30 to 90 day gap between the Planning Commission’s theoretical approval and when the proposal will appear on a County Council agenda.

